ToI group editor in flap over honorary doctorate


Bennett, Coleman bossman Samir Jain, it is said, doesn’t like his editors becoming the news instead of quietly packaging it in the newsroom. A test of that famous kink comes in Bangalore, where the helmsman of The Times of India group’s Kannada daily has been hogging the headlines for all the wrong reasons.

On January 25, Vishweshwar Bhat, editor of the mass-circulation daily Vijaya Karnataka, was shortlisted for an honorary doctorate degree by his alma mater Karnatak University in Dharwad. ToI reported that Bhat’s name had been cleared by the governor of the State, H.R. Bharadwaj, who is also the chancellor of the University.

So far, so good.

But trouble first came from the local unit of the Berlin-based “coalition against corruption”, Transparency International. On February 5, the chairman of TI’s Karnataka chapter, the former high court judge M.F. Saldanha, shot off a letter to the University and to the governor questioning the choice of the journalist.

“…the person concerned has been primarily responsible for instigating and fuelling communal hatred by regularly publishing extremely volatile and offensive articles and editorials in his paper, all directed against the minorities, particularly the Christians and Muslims as also against Dalits,” read a section of Justice Saldanha’s letter to the University.

The following day, February 6, Vijaya Karnataka carried a brief news report stating that Bhat had decided to decline the University honour due to “personal reasons”.

Today, Deccan Chronicle, which competes with The Times of India in Bangalore, Hyderabad and Madras has front-paged a story claiming that the Governor has ordered an “inquiry” into the decision of the University to honour Bhat.

Bhat has been at the receiving end of protests by Dalits in recent weeks.

Late last year, the Bangalore police commissioner Shankar Bidari attributed a series of negative reports about the functioning of the city’s police in Vijaya Karnataka to his decision to turn down Bhat’s request for gunmen in view of a perceived “threat” to his life.

Letter: courtesy Flickr

Newspaper facsimiles: courtesy Deccan Chronicle and Vijaya Karnataka


Also read: Is management responsible for content too?


  1. mysore peshva

    a superb roundup — one that is successful in not betraying the author’s own biases!

  2. sahana Rao

    Really good story.
    Most of the kannada media forgot to report this hard news.
    He edits not only BCCL’s Kannada daily but is also boss of all other like-minded kannada editors..

  3. vimarshaki

    this is really something peculiar. And why V Bhat is silent, if the complaints against him are not genuine?

  4. sahana

    Why he is silent ? Because, he is a shrewd politician and not editor !

    And the latest rumour is that URA & orher,Js M.F. Saldhana, Baraguru Ramachandrappa and others separately complained to BCCL chairman against Bhat..

  5. uday

    Doctorate for his service in Journalism?
    Vijay karnataka was built to its current level by D.Mahadevappa (who is completely forgotten)

    1. Muttu


      Yes,VK is build by Mr.D.Mahadevappa.This VB not done anything to VK.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.