The vanishing art of the narrative

The by-elections to the Chamundeshwari constituency are just a couple of days away. And now is as good a time as any to ask a simple question: Have English language journalists completely lost the art of painting a picture?

Make no mistake, dozens of journalists are doing a thankless job of bringing the elections to their readers. The interviews, the profiles, the controversies, and the daily “routines” are all coming through fine.

But let’s not confuse quantity for quality. Because, at the end of the day, much of all this is he-said, she-said stuff.

Certainly, this is bread and butter stuff for newspapers. But the questions we in journalism should be asking ourselves is: is the lay reader, who has probably seen the television news last night, really waking up in the morning to re-read some more of what he had heard/seen?

More pertinently, is this all that we can produce these days?

He said, she said.

One suspects that the scenario is no different in the Kannada newspapers but that is no justification for the anodyne, colourless reportage we have seen in the last fortnight. Indian elections produce have often provided some of the most scintillating reporting.

M J Akbar, Chandan Mitra, Sankarshan Thakur, Tarun Tejpal et al, have produced riveting reportage.

Why can’t we? Don’t we have that kind of wordsmiths any longer? Or don’t we have the fire in the belly? Or, worse, don’t we just care?

4 Comments

  1. KPchamcha

    See. KP fan worried unncessarily. I told him that KP would make a special posts from Mysore. BTW KP why don’t you do some wordsmithing on chamundeshwari polls, instead of cribbing and whining and complaining and ranting and heaving and deluxing in this obscure, remote, indistinct, ossified, gonified, gonarified spot of WWW.
    KPchamcha

  2. KPchamcha's karcha

    Cheer up! VTwale. why is suddenly everyone cribbing. Circulation is going up, ad revenue increasing and reporters say the first thing every babu and a politician and rival paperwalas they meet exclaim “hey where did u get that report man!”.

    for an akbar there is an ammachi, for a mitra a nair, for a thakur a dixit and for a tejpal a KP.

    Indulge in self-praise not in self-flaggellation. If the reportage is not good, if subbing is no more than raping and design is modern art, sufferer is the reader man, reader, not VTwala.

    If that bugger has no complaints, what is your problem children?

  3. u know hu

    amen. god bless the blogger and commentators. the blog spot looks more like a gladiators ring.

  4. u know hu

    amen. god bless the blogger and commentators. the blog spot looks more like a gladiators ring! good show. better to slug it out rather acting serious and boring the world.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.